Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Tonight.

Syesha
Got to Get You Into My Life
Grade: 4 as usual, she's put me to sleep.

Chikeze
She's a Woman
Grade: 9 FINALLY! Loved the intro, loved when he kicked it up. Great performance. I don't even think his vocal was great, but put on a great show.

Ramielle
In My Life
Grade: 2 how is she still around?

Jason
If I Fell
Grade: 5 a tuff song to try (one of my Lennon favorites); felt like he held back too much, didn't go for it when he should've. Kept stopping short.

Carly
Come Together
Grade: 4+ very disappointing for her. not helped by doing the worst Beatles "classic" in the canon.

David C
Eleanor Rigby
Grade: 3 amazingly dull. amazingly, the judges loved it. wtf?

Brooke
Brooke
Grade: 4 tuff song to hafta get over in 60 seconds. one of my all-time superslices. did nothing for me. amazingly, the judges loved it. wtf?

David H.
I Saw Her Standing There
Grade: 3+ didn't realize it was even possible to suck the life out of that song.congratulations, David. You did it.

Amanda
You Can't Do That
Grade: 8 best girl so far, and on a superslice. next up - Tina Turner impersonator in Vegas?

Michael
Across the Universe
Grade: 8 surprisingly forceful. maybe only cause he was loud, unlike everyone else's whispering and cooing into flowers. and I've never liked this guy. good for him.

Kristy Lee
eight Days a Week
Grade: 9 loved it. super corny, but thought it was super gutsy. exciting. of course, look who se's been surrounded by. doesnt take much with his group. and I think that version could be a hit on the radio today. liked it more as it went on. and of course, judges hated it. wtf?

David A.
We Can work It Out
Grade: 2 truly embarrassing to watch. is he forgettng words? terrible. but he wont get booted, kid has a fucking army backing him.

4 comments:

ope said...

overmeyer!

Anonymous said...

8 Days a Week

0

This isn't The Special American Idol.

ope said...

doo. dew.

BayonneMike said...

What album is "Brooke" on?