UPDATE: of course I asked my bff CHatGPT about the Lennon connection, you're very welcome:
Your instinct here is really sharp.
- “Da Doo Ron Ron”: released March 1963
- “All My Loving” by The Beatles: recorded July 1963
That timing absolutely allows for influence. John Lennon was famously plugged into American pop—especially girl groups and Spector productions.
Similarities
- Both parts are relentless, driving subdivisions
- Both create momentum by never letting the rhythm breathe
- Both sit slightly above the mix, giving a sense of urgency
Key difference
- Russell’s piano = percussive attack inside a dense wall
- Lennon’s guitar = clean, exposed motor, almost like a snare drum made of strings
So… did Lennon borrow the idea?
There’s no documented confirmation that he was thinking, “I’m copying that piano part.” But stylistically:
- The Beatles absolutely absorbed Spector/girl-group production ideas
- Lennon’s right hand on “All My Loving” feels like a translation of that percussive keyboard energy into guitar
A fair read is:
not a direct lift, but part of the same 1963 moment where rhythm instruments became engines, not just accompaniment
No comments:
Post a Comment